Federal appeals court rules TX voter ID law violates Voting Rights Act

AUSTIN, Texas (AP) -- A federal appeals court has ruled that Texas' strict voter ID law violates the Voting Rights Act and has ordered changes before the November election.
The ruling was issued Wednesday by the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The ruling instructs a lower court to make changes that fix the "discriminatory effect" of the 2011 law in the months leading up to this fall's election.
But the ruling said the lower court should make changes that disrupt this year's election season as little as possible.
The Obama administration took the unusual step of deploying the weight of the U.S. Justice Department into the case when it challenged the law.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton responded by putting out the following statement, "It is imperative that the State government safeguard our elections and ensures the integrity of our democratic process.  Preventing voter fraud is essential to accurately reflecting the will of Texas voters during elections, and it is unfortunate that this common-sense law, providing protections against fraud, was not upheld in its entirety."
Governor Abbott made the following statement, "The 5th Circuit rightly reversed the lower court’s finding of discriminatory purpose, but wrongly concluded the law had a discriminatory effect. Voter fraud is real, and it undermines the integrity of the election process. As Attorney General I prosecuted cases against voter fraud across the State, and Texas will continue to make sure there is no illegal voting at the ballot box."
The law has been challenged in court almost from the moment it was approved by the Republican-controlled Legislature in 2011 — and has now had a series of major court decisions go against it. Here are answers to some key questions about how Texas got this far and what happens next:


Q: How does this affect presidential voting?

A: The law went into effect in 2014, even as legal challenges continued to rage. Since then, Texas held three statewide elections under it with no reports of major voter disruptions.

During this year's presidential election, voters will still be required to show picture identification to cast ballots. But Wednesday's ruling means those who can't must still be allowed to vote — and that a lower court will have to help Texas devise ways to accommodate them.

It's not clear when those suggested fixes will be ready or how they will be implemented once they are.


Q: What is the Voting Rights Act?

A: A federal statute designed to prevent state and local governments from discriminating against minorities. Approved in 1965, it was a landmark civil rights statute that prohibited the use of poll taxes and other requirements designed to discourage blacks from voting in much of the post-Civil War South.

In its ruling, the Fifth Circuit suggested that Texas might have drafted its voter ID law with intent to discriminate. That appears to opens the door for a future legal challenge that Texas' law deliberately sought to hinder its poor and minority citizens from voting.

The Voting Rights Act used to require that Texas — and other, mostly southern states with histories of discrimination — get federal approval when redrawing electoral maps or making laws pertaining to elections. The U.S. Supreme Court struck that down in 2013.

Still, enough of the act survives that if Texas is found to have intentionally discriminated when it drafted its voter ID law, the state could again be forced to get federal "preclearance" on electoral laws.

The Texas Legislature reconvenes in January, though, and could modify the voter ID law enough to avoid such a challenge.

In the meantime, the ruling is a win for the President Barack Obama's administration, which used the U.S. Justice Department to challenge Texas' law as a way to fight ballot-box restrictions passed by conservative statehouses nationwide.


Q: What happened prior to the latest ruling?

A: In 2014, a federal judge in Corpus Christi declared Texas' law unconstitutional, likening it to a poll tax and saying it had a discriminatory effect on poor and minority voters. The law was eventually allowed to remain in effect because that ruling came so close to that November's election.

Last year, a three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit Court found that the law violated parts of the federal Voting Rights Act.

Then the full, 15-member 5th Circuit decided to hear the case, which included testimony that Hispanics were twice as likely and blacks three times more likely than whites to lack an acceptable ID under the law.

That set up Wednesday's ruling, in which the full Fifth Circuit rejected the notion that the law was like a poll tax, but upheld the previous decision that its effect was nonetheless discriminatory. It also included suggestions that the law perhaps intended to discriminate — meaning future cases could put Voting Rights Act preclearance back on the table for Texas.


Q: Is Texas' law unique?

A: More than 30 states have some form of voter ID law. Of those, nine have strict limitations on what forms of identification are valid.

But Texas is considered the strictest such law, since it spells out just seven forms of acceptable identification to vote. A concealed handgun license is valid, college IDs are not.

The Associated Press Contributed to this story
Up Next:

  • Popular

  • Recent


FOX 7 News streams at the following times (all times Central):

Monday - Friday

4:30 a.m. - 10 a.m.

12 p.m. - 12:30 p.m.

5 p.m. - 6 p.m.

9 p.m. - 10:30 p.m.


6 a.m. - 8 a.m.

6 p.m. to 6:30 p.m.

9 p.m. to 10 p.m.


6 a.m. - 8 a.m.

5 p.m. to 5:30 p.m.

9 p.m. to 10 p.m.

Schedule subject to change in the event of network sports coverage.

We also stream press conferences and other breaking news coverage from time to time. When we are not in a live newscast, you will see replays of the most recent broadcast.

To enter full screen Mode click the button.

For closed captioning, click on the button while in full screen mode.

Desktop/tablet users: To choose the stream's video quality, click on the button (while in full screen mode) and choose from 432p or 270p.

Mobile users:The video quality default is to your phone's settings.

Please allow time for buffering. If the stream stalls, refresh your browser. Thanks for watching

Stories You May Be Interested In - Includes Advertiser Stories