3 charged after child undergoes unnecessary surgery in alleged medical abuse case, deputies say

Three people face child neglect charges following an investigation into alleged medical child abuse and unsafe living conditions involving two children in Morgantown, West Virginia, according to the Monongalia County Sheriff’s Office. (Credit: Monong

Three people have been charged following an investigation into alleged medical child abuse and neglect involving two children in Morgantown, West Virginia, according to the Monongalia County Sheriff’s Office.

Detectives allege Emilee Guzman repeatedly gave medical professionals inaccurate and misleading information about one child’s medical conditions and nutritional needs, contributing to an invasive surgery authorities say was medically unnecessary.

The backstory:

The investigation began Oct. 8, 2026, after concerns surfaced about discrepancies in the child’s reported medical history and the welfare of both children living at a Morgantown residence, the sheriff’s office said.

Detectives reviewed medical records, interviewed medical professionals, executed search warrants and examined digital evidence. According to the sheriff’s office, investigators determined the surgery would not have occurred had accurate information been provided.

A child abuse pediatrician at WVU Medicine Children’s Hospital ultimately diagnosed medical child abuse, which the sheriff’s office described as commonly known as Munchausen syndrome by proxy.

Investigators also reported finding evidence of ongoing neglect involving both children, including hazardous and unsanitary living conditions and troubling treatment within the household. Authorities did not provide further details about that treatment.

Guzman faces one felony count of child neglect resulting in serious bodily injury. Caitlin Jean Meredith and Milton Alexander Guzman Cisneros each face two counts of child neglect creating risk of bodily injury.

What they're saying:

The sheriff’s office credited medical professionals at WVU Medicine Children’s and the West Virginia Department of Human Services’ Child Protective Services with assisting the investigation.

What you can do:

Anyone with information about the case or those charged is asked to contact the sheriff’s office’s Detective Division at 304-291-7260.

Authorities said they would not release additional information about the children to protect their identities and privacy.

The Source: Information in this story came from a statement released by the Monongalia County Sheriff’s Office detailing its investigation, the allegations against the three defendants and their charges. This story was reported from Los Angeles. 

West VirginiaCrime and Public Safety